Teachers’ Voices Fall on Deaf Ears in #SB6 Debate | Ecology of Education

Teachers’ Voices Fall on Deaf Ears in #SB6 Debate

Last night I attended the 8 hour Florida House Education Council Committee meeting on House Bill 7189 (HB7189), which is the companion to Senate Bill 6. While I never had a chance to testify, I left feeling both more inflamed by this legislation and more proud to be a member of this profession than I’ve been in a long time.

Over 120 people came to speak out against this bill.  Most were teachers, but there were also parents, principals, superintendents, and representatives from PTA, School Board Association, and Civic Concern in attendance.

There was bipartisan opposition with only partisan support among representatives.

Hour after hour I listened to teachers speak truth to power about schools, learning, and the reality of teaching in Florida.  Teachers who have been teaching for 20, 30, and nearly 40 years offered their thoughts and insights, all of them speaking eloquently and passionately.  They truly represented the best of our profession.

Common theme in many of their testimonies: Education in Florida is over-mandated and underfunded.

The question every representative supporting this draconian bill should have been asking them was this: How do we get more teachers like you in our state’s classrooms, and then what’s it going to take to get them to stay?

The main proponents speaking on behalf of the bill: Chamber of Commerce representatives, a spokesperson from Jeb Bush’s Foundation for Florida’s Future, and Florida’s Secretary of Education, Eric J. Smith.

I wondered why the Chamber of Commerce was so dedicated to this bill.

If they were in this for the best interest of students and tomorrow’s work force they would be citing the latest brain research, talking about creating innovative and engaging learning environments, and encouraging legislators to enact policies that provide students with meaningful learning experiences in which students apply skills in relevant contexts.

Their mantras would be:

  1. Let’s focus on job ready skills for helping Florida compete in a globalized world.
  2. Lets give these kids skills that can’t be shipped overseas.

Then, I found this clue in the evaluation of Florida’s Race to the Top application that shed light on the Chamber of Commerce’s intense interest:

A substantial amount of the resources requested are target(ed) to external vendors and contracted services as opposed to a systemic integration of the work into key functional units of the state department of education as well as other state agencies.

So . . . money will be pilfered from our schools and go to corporations . . .

How much money?

Well, turns out, this bill does not begin the testing portion until the 2013-2014 school year. However, during the next three years districts are required to allocate 5% of their budgets for development of the measures used to assess teachers in order to reward them.

Code: Development of standardized tests.

This 5% amounts to $900 million dollars siphoned from our already cash strapped districts and funneled to private companies.

And that is just the initial development costs.  The on-going costs will continue to rise as districts will be forced to pilfer from their treasuries in order to sustain the additional costs associated with additional tests.  (I’m still wondering, where exactly will the money to pay teachers more come from?)

At a time when districts are forced to eliminate programs and services due to budget cuts, teachers are paying for supplies out of pocket, and students must share textbooks because there are not enough for everyone, the legislature is mining schools to help companies profit.

There is a gross warping of education policy going on in Florida.

The Hillsborough Example

One irony in this dark comedy is that we have in our state an example of unions and policy makers working together to create a merit/performance pay plan that everyone can agree on.

Hillsborough County applied for (and won) a $100 million grant from the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation to create and implement a collaborative plan for differentiating teacher pay and measuring student growth.

In order to not negate the grant, legislators amended SB6 so that Hillsborough county would be exempt during their grant period.

Even so, numerous teachers from Hillsborough testified against HB7189 offering their district as an example of what can be accomplished when lawmakers and teachers work together.  As a principal remarked to the committee, “Rather than exempting them, we ought to be following their leadership.”

Teachers are not against using standardized testing to measure growth.  They aren’t against merit/performance pay.

What they are against:

  1. Being left out of major reform that does not include their input.
  2. State mandates that pillage from local districts’s limited funds to pay private companies.
  3. Reforms that do not promote meaningful learning.
  4. Deaf legislators.

It is time for Florida leadership to see the writing on the wall.  This railroading of the bill disrespects the professionalism of educators. And when teachers and districts do not support or stand behind these reform measures recruitment efforts to attract and keep the best and the brightest to our classrooms will be severely undermined.

Image: Bluejayway67

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

23 Responses to “Teachers’ Voices Fall on Deaf Ears in #SB6 Debate”

  1. April 6, 2010 at 2:06 pm #

    RT @prestwickhouse: Teachers’ Voices Fall on Deaf Ears http://bit.ly/aW3Mm2 via @jasonflom | Ecology of Education #sb6 #hb7189

  2. April 6, 2010 at 2:35 pm #

    RT @JasonFlom: RT @prestwickhouse: Teachers’ Voices Fall on Deaf Ears http://bit.ly/aW3Mm2 via @jasonflom | Ecology of Education #sb6 #hb7189

  3. April 6, 2010 at 5:49 pm #

    @sanborncamps The anti #sb6 op-ed did well. I meant 2 send 2 u (http://bit.ly/c3SHPq). Today's post on #hb7189: http://bit.ly/c1qReX

  4. April 6, 2010 at 7:41 pm #

    @VanessaSCassie There were over 120 speakers, 99.9% of which opposed. Inspiring to watch. What I wanted to say: http://bit.ly/c1qReX

  5. April 6, 2010 at 8:00 pm #

    RT @VanessaSCassie: An excellent blog post discussing the travesty of Florida Senate Bill 6 last night http://bit.ly/aVKG7s (by @JasonFlom)

  6. vanessacassie
    April 6, 2010 at 7:46 pm #

    Excellent thoughts Jason! You definitely would have followed the trend of eloquent speakers had you been given the chance. I completely agree that 99% of the committee had already made up their mind prior to this event — amounting in a waste of 8 hours, people's time and taxpayers' money for public lip service. Keep up your fight! Your Canadian counterparts are rooting for you 🙂

  7. April 7, 2010 at 2:30 am #

    @pammoran Teachers' Voices Fall on Deaf Ears http://bit.ly/c1qReX

  8. April 7, 2010 at 4:48 am #

    RT @JasonFlom: @pammoran Teachers' Voices Fall on Deaf Ears http://bit.ly/c1qReX

  9. April 7, 2010 at 8:50 am #

    Teachers’ Voices Fall on Deaf Ears | Ecology of Education http://bit.ly/b0HgYn

  10. April 7, 2010 at 4:26 pm #

    "Let me repeat that: $2.7 billion from our schools — our classrooms – handed to the testing industry" http://bit.ly/ar4egj via @Jasonflom

  11. April 7, 2010 at 4:48 pm #

    RT @joe_bower: "Let me repeat: $2.7 B from our schs – our classrooms – handed to the testing industry" http://bit.ly/ar4egj via @Jasonflom

  12. April 7, 2010 at 5:08 pm #

    RT @joe_bower: "Let me repeat $2.7bn from our schools -our classrooms –handed to the testing industry" http://bit.ly/ar4egj via @Jasonflom

  13. robmcentarffer
    April 7, 2010 at 7:06 pm #

    “$2.7 billion from our schools ” – we need to be shouting about this quite a bit more than we are. The hidden (barely hidden!) costs are even higher: these data are usable by policymakers, but rarely useful by teachers and students. In addition to all the obvious potential costs (to instructional time, student motivation, etc.) an over emphasis on these kinds of tests sends the message to students that school is about scores, not about learning.

  14. April 7, 2010 at 11:30 pm #

    RT @joe_bower $2.7 billion from our schools/classrooms handed 2 the #testing industry http://bit.ly/ar4egj via @Jasonflom #education #USA

  15. April 8, 2010 at 3:24 pm #

    @umarsattar What direction is that? Siphoning money away from classrooms & funneling to private companies? http://bit.ly/c1qReX #SB6

  16. April 13, 2010 at 1:31 pm #

    @kevinkelso Here is a piece that draws out some of the underlying issues w/ #SB6. http://bit.ly/c1qReX

  17. April 20, 2010 at 1:23 pm #

    @tvanderark Crist's #SB6 veto: http://bit.ly/9f7o10 FL GOP Legislators' letter: http://bit.ly/9jn1cv Tchrs left behind: http://bit.ly/c1qReX


  1. Tweets that mention Teachers’ Voices Fall on Deaf Ears | Ecology of Education -- Topsy.com - April 6, 2010

    […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Jason Flom , Concerned Parent. Concerned Parent said: RT @prestwickhouse: Teachers’ Voices Fall on Deaf Ears http://bit.ly/aW3Mm2 via @jasonflom | Ecology of Education #sb6 #hb7189 […]

  2. Travel perks will dry up in water districts - April 6, 2010

    […] Teachers' Voices Fall on Deaf Ears | Ecology of Education […]

  3. uberVU - social comments - April 6, 2010

    Social comments and analytics for this post…

    This post was mentioned on Twitter by JasonFlom: @sanborncamps The anti #sb6 op-ed did well. I meant 2 send 2 u (http://bit.ly/c3SHPq). Today’s post on #hb7189: http://bit.ly/c1qReX

  4. Connecting the Dots in Florida: Inside SB6’s Players | Ecology of Education - April 11, 2010

    […] there are the private/charter / voucher schools… more specal interests… (You do a great job in your article with […]

  5. Teacher Uprising of 2010: It’s About Collaboration, Not Merit Pay! | Ecology of Education - July 17, 2010

    […] The prevailing wisdom seems to have been, legislators and bureaucrats alone know what is best for our schools, not the teachers with years of experience serving in the classrooms.  As a result we have been summarily left out of many conversations, SB6 included. […]

  6. Tickets-News.de - September 23, 2011

    … Ecologyofeducation.net…

    […] Read More here: ecologyofeducation.net/wsite/?p=2035 […]…

Leave a Reply